I'm at a stage in the novel I'm working on that I want to hear feedback from a handful of readers.
But first, before I embarrass myself, I need to read and hear it for myself.
Occasionally, in the past, I've recorded my own reading of a short story. But, for now, I won't take the time to read 15,000 words aloud. Instead, I just took the first 75 pages of the novel and, using Automator on the Mac, had the machine record a reading.
Hearing your own writing read to you like this is immensely helpful. Make no mistake, even with modern technology, standard computers with off-the-shelf software do not read well. They do, however, do a good enough job to get some sense of rhythm and a very good sense of things like unintended repeated words.
Within the first few minutes of listening, I made note of half-a-dozen spots that needed something for rhythm. And this is true after having read the first couple chapters countless times during the early editing process.
Hearing it aloud is just plain different.
It's been a while since I did any of this kind of work with a Windows machine. But I know they are as capable (perhaps with a little bit more inconvenience) of reading/recording your material for you.
Give it a try and see if it doesn't help you spot problems in your writing that you would otherwise miss.
An unknown novelist attempting to grow into a little-known novelist. I offer--free of charge--writing tips, anecdotes, short fiction, and assorted ramblings (with photographs and other random tid-bits thrown in for good measure)
Wednesday, February 03, 2010
Sunday, January 31, 2010
Simple But Helpful

My editor of choice (Scrivener on the Mac) has a full-screen editing mode that I just started using. It's a godsend for the easily distracted. Somehow, it prevents me from constantly glancing at my e-mail inbox, keeps my eyes from wandering over to the Facebook status tray to look for pointless new updates.
Many editors have this full-screen feature (though Scrivener is by far my favorite). I suggest giving it a try if you have a need to improve your focus.
Thursday, January 28, 2010
Values vs. Moods
It's easy in life to be driven by moods.
Even someone who typically runs on level ground can defer to moods more often than he should.
Without a plan that's been crafted to align behavior to values, the values will lose to moods more often than not. And the specific outcome will be unpredictable but predictably bad.
Most of the goals worth having represent some sort of ambition requiring a long-term commitment. Moods, even among the most even-tempered people, are sadly far too variable to bank on them guiding you in any sort of consistent direction.
I feel this dilemma acutely now as I'm being challenged personally more than I ever have and am, at the same time, fighting to reach several new meaningful goals.
I am desperate to chase my bigger goals, even as moods too-often try to direct me places I don't want to go.
This kind of thinking, aligning actions to values rather than moods, applies to many areas of life, but it fits particularly well with the notion of writing and inspiration.
Waiting for inspiration means, in essence, waiting for the right mood. I'm working hard not to do that and suggest that you do the same. The value, to me, is finishing a novel that makes me proud. In order to do that, I have to produce consistently, irrespective of my moods.
Even someone who typically runs on level ground can defer to moods more often than he should.
Without a plan that's been crafted to align behavior to values, the values will lose to moods more often than not. And the specific outcome will be unpredictable but predictably bad.
Most of the goals worth having represent some sort of ambition requiring a long-term commitment. Moods, even among the most even-tempered people, are sadly far too variable to bank on them guiding you in any sort of consistent direction.
I feel this dilemma acutely now as I'm being challenged personally more than I ever have and am, at the same time, fighting to reach several new meaningful goals.
I am desperate to chase my bigger goals, even as moods too-often try to direct me places I don't want to go.
This kind of thinking, aligning actions to values rather than moods, applies to many areas of life, but it fits particularly well with the notion of writing and inspiration.
Waiting for inspiration means, in essence, waiting for the right mood. I'm working hard not to do that and suggest that you do the same. The value, to me, is finishing a novel that makes me proud. In order to do that, I have to produce consistently, irrespective of my moods.
Basic Dialog Mechanics
Dialog seems to have a particular reliance on a sensible rhythm for its power. This is true of all writing, but especially true, I think, for dialog.
I can't generate a useful definition for good rhythm, but like the supreme court justice said about defining pornography, I know it when I see it.
There are certain very low-level mechanic aspects of writing dialog that can make a good difference, though.
Attribution Styles
How do you attach a given piece of dialog to a given character?
There are, mechanically, a handful of methods.
Basic Tag
"I know," he said.
He said, "I know." This one seems to have fallen into disfavor. It feels anachronistic.
"I have no idea," Danny said. "But I'll let you know when I find out."
"I have no idea, but I'll let you know when I find out," Danny said.
I prefer the first of the two above. It's a common mistake to push the tag too late into the character's dialog. We need to know quickly, for both rhythm and understanding, who's speaking.
If you're going to use this style of tag, you are, for the most part, best off sticking to 'said' and 'asked.' There are obvious times, liked a shouted sentence, that you should say they shouted. But don't get much more creative than that. Said and asked have the added benefit of being essentially invisible to most readers.
Action Tag
Here's an action tag--rather than the basic he-said, she-said approach. It tends to be closer to invisible (a very good thing) than those tags are.
Danny winced and shook his head. "I have no idea, but I'll let you know when I find out."
"I have no idea." Danny shook his head. "But I'll let you know when I find out."
No Tag
There's currently a strong preference for tagless runs of dialog. Readers like for pages to move, and it works, as a sort of artificial trick, to make the story feel like it's moving along, as well.
Carla stood nearby, simply staring. "Why?"
"I like glue."
"Again, I'll ask you, Why?"
"Curls my toes. And my nose hairs."
The risk, in long runs of this kind of dialog, is that it can feel very thin. It's also easy to write scenes that have no rhythm save an unchecked gallop.
Tid-Bits
* End with a comma if the tag is a continuation of the sentence, a period otherwise.
* Get the rhythm of the tag's placement right:
"Why in God's name are you sniffing glue?" Carla asked.
"I like glue, because of the way it curls my toes and my nose hairs," Nick said.
In the previous sentence, the tag comes too late (though this is not a terrible example).
Instead, something like the following would work better.
"I like glue," Nick said. "Because of the way it curls my toes and my nose hairs."
This is an improvement because, most often, it's best to finish with dialog, rather than a tag. And, in this case, the tag is in the best place rhythmically.
* Forget the editorial
"I love you with all my heart," she said lovingly.
This is obviously intentionally bad. But the point is, either the dialog carries the tone or it doesn't. Your editorial only gets in the way. If the dialog hasn't carried the intended tone, it's too late for your editorial to help. I've already read it and, if I'm paying attention, had it ring in my ears in my own way.
If the dialog doesn't say what you'd intended, in the way you'd intended, the editorial aspect of the tag is unlikely to fix the problem.
I'll paraphrase John Gardner here--though I think he was quoting someone else--and say that writing should create a vivid and continuous dream in the reader's mind. When you're dealing with the mechanics of dialog, do your best to make those mechanics invisible, to avoid interruption of that vivid and continuous dream.
I'll refine this article and add a few thoughts soon, but I thought there was enough here to be worth putting out.
I can't generate a useful definition for good rhythm, but like the supreme court justice said about defining pornography, I know it when I see it.
There are certain very low-level mechanic aspects of writing dialog that can make a good difference, though.
Attribution Styles
How do you attach a given piece of dialog to a given character?
There are, mechanically, a handful of methods.
Basic Tag
"I know," he said.
He said, "I know." This one seems to have fallen into disfavor. It feels anachronistic.
"I have no idea," Danny said. "But I'll let you know when I find out."
"I have no idea, but I'll let you know when I find out," Danny said.
I prefer the first of the two above. It's a common mistake to push the tag too late into the character's dialog. We need to know quickly, for both rhythm and understanding, who's speaking.
If you're going to use this style of tag, you are, for the most part, best off sticking to 'said' and 'asked.' There are obvious times, liked a shouted sentence, that you should say they shouted. But don't get much more creative than that. Said and asked have the added benefit of being essentially invisible to most readers.
Action Tag
Here's an action tag--rather than the basic he-said, she-said approach. It tends to be closer to invisible (a very good thing) than those tags are.
Danny winced and shook his head. "I have no idea, but I'll let you know when I find out."
"I have no idea." Danny shook his head. "But I'll let you know when I find out."
No Tag
There's currently a strong preference for tagless runs of dialog. Readers like for pages to move, and it works, as a sort of artificial trick, to make the story feel like it's moving along, as well.
Carla stood nearby, simply staring. "Why?"
"I like glue."
"Again, I'll ask you, Why?"
"Curls my toes. And my nose hairs."
The risk, in long runs of this kind of dialog, is that it can feel very thin. It's also easy to write scenes that have no rhythm save an unchecked gallop.
Tid-Bits
* End with a comma if the tag is a continuation of the sentence, a period otherwise.
- "I hate it when you do that," Janey said.
- "I hate it when you do that." Janey turned an angry look his way.
* Get the rhythm of the tag's placement right:
"Why in God's name are you sniffing glue?" Carla asked.
"I like glue, because of the way it curls my toes and my nose hairs," Nick said.
In the previous sentence, the tag comes too late (though this is not a terrible example).
Instead, something like the following would work better.
"I like glue," Nick said. "Because of the way it curls my toes and my nose hairs."
This is an improvement because, most often, it's best to finish with dialog, rather than a tag. And, in this case, the tag is in the best place rhythmically.
* Forget the editorial
"I love you with all my heart," she said lovingly.
This is obviously intentionally bad. But the point is, either the dialog carries the tone or it doesn't. Your editorial only gets in the way. If the dialog hasn't carried the intended tone, it's too late for your editorial to help. I've already read it and, if I'm paying attention, had it ring in my ears in my own way.
If the dialog doesn't say what you'd intended, in the way you'd intended, the editorial aspect of the tag is unlikely to fix the problem.
I'll paraphrase John Gardner here--though I think he was quoting someone else--and say that writing should create a vivid and continuous dream in the reader's mind. When you're dealing with the mechanics of dialog, do your best to make those mechanics invisible, to avoid interruption of that vivid and continuous dream.
I'll refine this article and add a few thoughts soon, but I thought there was enough here to be worth putting out.
Tuesday, January 26, 2010
Newsy Bits
I've just started pulling together the short stories I've written that I don't look back on with scorn. I'm planning to publish them as a Smashwords book and link it from the main page of this blog.
Smashwords is a free platform for publishing e-books to multiple platforms (including Kindle and Barnes and Noble's Nook).
It should be a fun exercise, and it will give any readers of this blog a chance to figure out if they'd be smart to ignore every piece of advice I have about writing. I'm planning to have this book together in the next few weeks. It will be woefully short, but, on the bright side, free.
I've also started working on a series that I wish I'd had when I was a true neophyte writer. It's a bunch of short posts about the mechanics of writing and possible solutions to story-telling problems. I'll cover things like, How do I decide how much physical description to give in a scene?, How do I deal with the attribution of dialog to characters?, and How do I figure out where to begin and end a scene?
I don't pretend to have the 'right' answer to any of these questions. But I do have an answer. And when you're new to story-telling--and you're struggling--any help seems . . . well . . . helpful.
These articles will start trickling in by the end of the week.
Smashwords is a free platform for publishing e-books to multiple platforms (including Kindle and Barnes and Noble's Nook).
It should be a fun exercise, and it will give any readers of this blog a chance to figure out if they'd be smart to ignore every piece of advice I have about writing. I'm planning to have this book together in the next few weeks. It will be woefully short, but, on the bright side, free.
I've also started working on a series that I wish I'd had when I was a true neophyte writer. It's a bunch of short posts about the mechanics of writing and possible solutions to story-telling problems. I'll cover things like, How do I decide how much physical description to give in a scene?, How do I deal with the attribution of dialog to characters?, and How do I figure out where to begin and end a scene?
I don't pretend to have the 'right' answer to any of these questions. But I do have an answer. And when you're new to story-telling--and you're struggling--any help seems . . . well . . . helpful.
These articles will start trickling in by the end of the week.
Saturday, January 23, 2010
Big Writing Day
For the first time in a few weeks, I had a writing day that makes me proud.
Working on a big dramatic scene that pretty well summarizes the whole point of the novel to me, I wrote like the wind. Well over a thousand words.
It feels, as I re-read it, dramatic and reasonably balanced. It's incomplete still and will need re-writing. But the core of it is there and seems--with my admittedly very little distance--to be working pretty well.
As I wrote, I actually felt some of what I would hope a reader might feel reading it.
It's amazing to me how powerful a thing it is, how great it feels and how complete, when the writing goes well. All manner of sins get erased in that rush.
Very nice, indeed.
Working on a big dramatic scene that pretty well summarizes the whole point of the novel to me, I wrote like the wind. Well over a thousand words.
It feels, as I re-read it, dramatic and reasonably balanced. It's incomplete still and will need re-writing. But the core of it is there and seems--with my admittedly very little distance--to be working pretty well.
As I wrote, I actually felt some of what I would hope a reader might feel reading it.
It's amazing to me how powerful a thing it is, how great it feels and how complete, when the writing goes well. All manner of sins get erased in that rush.
Very nice, indeed.
Friday, January 22, 2010
Seeking Grace
In October last year, several big events in my life conspired to knock me convincingly on my heels. There were moments when I felt like I was incapable of handling what came next, unable to make a sensible decision in any given moment.
Considering that I've slogged through some pretty deep, fast-moving water in the past, this state of affairs shook me.
That feeling convinced me to go seek help in the form of therapy.
Though there were (and are) unpleasant situations over which I have no control, I have, for the most part managed to take control of the things that seemed reasonably graspable. And that achievement has made all the difference.
In the last couple weeks, however, with the help of a few taxing events, I've felt myself slipping a bit, felt the breathless panic of powerlessness creeping in.
In talking with my therapist, his goal is that, in the heat of battle--talking about one particular interpersonal struggle here--I get to a place that I handle things with a sort of emotionless equanimity. That's not how he put it, exactly. He said to find my own sort of Zen place to help me fend off the fury with the least possible bleeding.
But he knows what should be obvious; it ain't easy.
The best you can hope for in situations like this, I think--the Holy Grail of responses--is to handle the moments with humor and grace. And, historically, before the toughest of this struggle, I think I've done a reasonable job with this. Second comes my therapist's recommendation, a steady sort of equanimity. Third is the head-in-hands, hair-on-fire survival mode.
Today, in the heat of battle, I fell back on the last. Almost immediately, I was annoyed with myself for it, for being incapable of even approximating what my therapist was recommending. I let the situation, in essence, own me. Let it tear me up. And I know I must do better.
It's hard, after all, to chase goals when your hair's on fire. And goal-chasing--in one form or another--is, in the end, what 2010 is about for me.
But sometimes the lowest form of survival is the best I can manage.
Considering that I've slogged through some pretty deep, fast-moving water in the past, this state of affairs shook me.
That feeling convinced me to go seek help in the form of therapy.
Though there were (and are) unpleasant situations over which I have no control, I have, for the most part managed to take control of the things that seemed reasonably graspable. And that achievement has made all the difference.
In the last couple weeks, however, with the help of a few taxing events, I've felt myself slipping a bit, felt the breathless panic of powerlessness creeping in.
In talking with my therapist, his goal is that, in the heat of battle--talking about one particular interpersonal struggle here--I get to a place that I handle things with a sort of emotionless equanimity. That's not how he put it, exactly. He said to find my own sort of Zen place to help me fend off the fury with the least possible bleeding.
But he knows what should be obvious; it ain't easy.
The best you can hope for in situations like this, I think--the Holy Grail of responses--is to handle the moments with humor and grace. And, historically, before the toughest of this struggle, I think I've done a reasonable job with this. Second comes my therapist's recommendation, a steady sort of equanimity. Third is the head-in-hands, hair-on-fire survival mode.
Today, in the heat of battle, I fell back on the last. Almost immediately, I was annoyed with myself for it, for being incapable of even approximating what my therapist was recommending. I let the situation, in essence, own me. Let it tear me up. And I know I must do better.
It's hard, after all, to chase goals when your hair's on fire. And goal-chasing--in one form or another--is, in the end, what 2010 is about for me.
But sometimes the lowest form of survival is the best I can manage.
Thursday, January 21, 2010
Wednesday, January 20, 2010
Perfect Moment, Perfect Place
A few years back, on a brisk August night, my cousin and I sat in chaises on this New Hampshire beach chatting and watching falling stars over the lake. One star, in particular, made our evening.
At first, it appeared as a nearly stationary light in the sky. The only visible difference was a sort of vibration. Eventually, after perhaps a minute, its movement became more visible. Slowly, we figured out that it was, indeed, a falling star and that it was falling right toward us.
The whole show, the time from original spotting to fading away, took perhaps two minutes. Sounds impossible, I'm sure, but it happened.
Years earlier, as youngsters, this same cousin and I had lain on the ground--she and I remember differently about exactly where--and watched falling stars for a long time. That, too, was magical.
These moments come to me occasionally--like now, when I'm struggling with loneliness--and they put a smile on my face.
At first, it appeared as a nearly stationary light in the sky. The only visible difference was a sort of vibration. Eventually, after perhaps a minute, its movement became more visible. Slowly, we figured out that it was, indeed, a falling star and that it was falling right toward us.
The whole show, the time from original spotting to fading away, took perhaps two minutes. Sounds impossible, I'm sure, but it happened.
Years earlier, as youngsters, this same cousin and I had lain on the ground--she and I remember differently about exactly where--and watched falling stars for a long time. That, too, was magical.
These moments come to me occasionally--like now, when I'm struggling with loneliness--and they put a smile on my face.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Free Short Story
My short story, Agendas , is free on Kindle from April 10, 2025 to April 14 2025. If you like it, consider reading my novel, Learning to Sw...
-
I just found out yesterday that a very good friend of mine, Marilyn D'Andrea, died unexpectedly recently. She was a lover of writers and...
-
read part I first part II 6. Vary your cadence and pacing Different people think differently. Different people present differently. Make ...



